User blog comment:Rtys8/Wearing out again...../@comment-16526045-20140822155511/@comment-4738138-20140822161233

I have the theory that Lisette story may be something that Johanna had created. She is a phenomenon after all, she can manipulate and travelling in time as much as she wants. The reason why is how Johanna appeared as Maria in If story. There is anachronism there as Johanna was supposed to be the founder of Index, and there she appeared as a sister living in the village Index planned to detsroy. That may be a parallel she created herself, to see what would happened in this universe where Verard didn't have been killed.

You are right point by point. Liselotte can't be really saved, because she had originally been created by Michel, another phenomenon who  created chaos. Even though her love for Verard humanized her a bit, she was still created by destruction. Her love was a crazy love as she was ready to destroy the world for love. That's why Verard's wish couldn't be really realized. Lisette, who is pure at heart and a victim, was the one to be saved. I think maybe Verard could see some hints of Lisette in Liselotte however because Liz has a sweet side to him, so Lisette may not have been entirely lost.

Personally I always hated Johanna. She deserved to die to me.